There, I said it.
Before the big announcement came, one site or another (I think it was Wired but I can’t remember) posted something about Facebook possibly offering “widgets.” Now, “widgets” — in the WordPress and Technorati senses, are neat. “Plugins” — in the Firefox sense — are also neat.
Facebook applications are useless.
It’s worth saying again: Facebook applications are useless.
What could have been a neat way to add RSS feeds and other useful things to one’s profile wound up nothing more than a way to determine what kind of zombie one is. (Useless.) Back in the day, we had sites like Tickle for that kind of stuff. If you wanted to find out which Friends character you were most like, you took a quiz on a website and then posted the results on your blog where people could skip over them if they wanted to. The chance to annoy your friends was limited entirely to e-mailing a link to the quiz to anyone you wanted to, and who did that? Nobody. There was none of this inviting everyone on your contact list to add some ridiculous application that’s become so rampant that a Facebook group demanding the banning of application invitations has garnered more than a million members.
Then things like this happen and people start spazzing. Techcrunch is correct:
It is failing in a very public way. This is the risk big brands take when they put an app on Facebook. It had better work or else the world will hear about it.
Facebook is a handy tool for keeping in touch with people, sharing photos and videos and links. The applications that either started out with it or were introduced shortly after its rise to prominence — photos, video, events, posted items and groups — are its best features. Even the somewhat more tolerable third-party applications, some of which I’d added myself before deleting them, made me shake my head. And let’s not forget that the most popular third-party Facebook application led to a lawsuit.
Web 2.0 is an amazing thing. Facebook is handling it badly. There’s a place for bits of script that tell you whether you’re a Jedi master, but this isn’t it.